Shakespeare knew that nothing pulls at our heartstrings quite like star-crossed lovers, and that truth hits hard in All of You, directed and written by Will Bridges, with co-writer Brett Goldstein.
Set in the near future, the film follows Simon (played by Goldstein) and Laura (Imogen Poots), best friends who are obviously in love but struggle to express their feelings. In this world, scientists have created a soulmate test, which Simon reluctantly pays for Laura to take. It reveals that her soulmate is a man named Lucas (Steven Cree). She marries him and they have a child, while Simon remains a supportive presence in her life, attempting to date Laura’s friend Andrea (Zawe Ashton). Eventually, Simon and Laura can’t hide their feelings any longer and start a passionate affair.
Despite the sci-fi twist of the soulmate test, the story unfolds like a classic romantic drama, elevated by its sharp writing and powerful performances. Goldstein’s portrayal of yearning is so intense that it almost made me feel physically ill—it’s a raw and visceral depiction of unrequited love. The chemistry between Goldstein and Poots is electric; every moment they share feels charged with longing. Their intimate scenes are genuinely steamy, adding an extra layer of tension to their forbidden romance.
Goldstein, known for his tough exterior and colorful language, is a true romantic at heart, a trait familiar to fans of Ted Lasso. He excels at crafting swoon-worthy gestures and heart-wrenching breakups, but his real strength lies in capturing the essence of heartbreak. Simon’s fixation on Laura makes it hard for him to love anyone else, and his pain and desire are laid bare. Poots is a fantastic counterpart, portraying a complex character who loves two good men in very different ways.
Bridges masterfully creates mood throughout the film, contrasting the warmth of Simon and Laura’s time together in lush, pastoral settings with the cold, gritty city when they are apart. The film is filled with tender moments and quiet conversations, showcasing Goldstein’s knack for blending humor with heartbreak. It’s the kind of laughter that comes through tears, making their relationship feel vibrant and alive.
I found myself watching much of the film with my heart in my throat, drawn into the emotional turmoil of this doomed romance. It’s refreshing to see a film that sticks to its simple premise without relying on over-the-top plot twists to keep its lovers apart. In a time when romantic dramas often get bogged down in complicated concepts, All of You stands out as a deeply human story.
This film challenges the idea of soulmates, suggesting that love is more about choices than fate. The small decisions Simon and Laura make create immense difficulties and regrets in their relationship. However, it doesn’t offer easy answers to the messy nature of love and desire. Instead, it leaves us feeling just as shattered as its characters, delivering a tearjerker that resonates deeply. Watching All of You is like pressing on a bruise—painful but oddly satisfying. Grade: A-
